2013-05-24
My evening was not ordinary, it was burdened with news from the Arab and Islamic world about protests against the production of a film insulting the Prophet, peace be upon him, called “Innocence of Muslims”. Part of those demonstrations were indeed in support of the noble Prophet, and another part seemed to me to be recording a political stance, nothing more. Regardless, I decided to escape from this huge amount of news to my imaginary world, where I practice my human nature and listen to songs that help me reconcile with myself and clear my mind to advance with the mentality of a warrior to the upcoming battles.
This escape did not last long, as my phone soon rang and I received a text message whose request surprised me greatly. In the message, which was apparently circulated via mobile phones, he asked me to start a campaign to boycott YouTube and Google for 3 days starting today for their refusal of requests to remove the film insulting the Holy Prophet from the YouTube website, which is naturally owned by Google. He also asked me to circulate the message to others so that it reaches the largest number of “boycotters”!
Boycott YouTube?! Is the subject applicable?! For 3 days?! Why is YouTube being punished in the first place?! And why do we have to direct our anger and rage at Google?! Why do we have to respond to the publication of this offensive film in the first place?!
I have no doubt that the aim of the film is to harm the Islamic religion, stir up strife and ignite sectarianism. It must be noted that the level of the film is low and poor and exceeds the limits of naivety, and that those convicted are those who contributed to its production, and no one else. Hostility towards anyone just because he shares the religion of those in charge of the film is an act no less bad than the film, and even achieves its goals. It is important to note here that there is no chapter in the constitution of any country that defines itself as democratic that criminalizes attacks on religious sanctities (for example, offensive cartoons of the Prophet), because including such a chapter in the constitution would incite discrimination and religious fanaticism and undermine freedom of expression, which is prohibited by many countries, which explicitly stipulate in their constitutions that the state is prohibited from practicing some acts of fanaticism or religious preference within its borders. Accordingly, the presence of religion in most constitutions of countries that define themselves as democratic is limited to provisions on freedom of belief and preventing the state from discrimination and religious fanaticism.
The above means that freedom of expression is equal to freedom of belief and religion. On the one hand, it is considered a natural and protected right, but on the other hand, it is also a right subject to moral controls and is dependent on not attacking others. International law deals with it clearly: if we review Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (which is the most important international document concerned with regulating human rights worldwide), we will find that it states that “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.” However, if we look at Article 20 of the same article, we will find that it “condemns incitement to war, incitement to national, racial or religious hatred and any form of discrimination, hostility or violence.”
Kholoud Masalha: Hebrew Media Coordinator at the Media Center