Amal Jamal: Chance and Politics

2013-05-24

Amal Jamal

Director General of the Media Center and Lecturer in the Department of Political Science at Tel Aviv University

I would like to begin by questioning whether politics and chance are companions; in politics there are no coincidences, and in coincidence there is no politics. This does not mean that certain political decisions cannot appear or be presented as if they were the result of chance. Politics exploits chance to remove the political character from politics and present it as a mere coincidence in order to limit objections to it or to not alert those who object to it. It, politics, sometimes means presenting certain matters as mere coincidence in order to erase their political character, despite the prior planning for them and despite the clear calculations of profit and loss in the matter.

The processes of wrapping political decisions in the guise of a professional and objective decision represent the exploitation of naivety for the sake of politics; Although exploiting chance sometimes belittles minds and sometimes shows disrespect, it succeeds in achieving its goals more effectively than other mechanisms, especially coercive ones. When chance becomes part of a well-defined and clearly defined process in political decision-making, it reflects the deliberate disregard for minds and the lack of respect for peers, because it expresses a state of dominance in which the powerful person does not need to cover his decisions with any cover, and presents them confidently, clarifying his intentions and goals. Dominance is the ability to transform the prevailing thinking into an integral part of the existential logic of the public, and this is the ultimate state of influence and power. But at the same time, this is also a weakness, because when the logic of the absolute majority of a given society identifies with the political decision, the dominance of the prevailing thought becomes an internal enemy that can lead to a deterioration into blind collective narcissism, which has always ended in bloody and inhumane decisions and operations, as was the case in Franco’s Spain, Pinochet’s Chile, the military junta rule in Argentina, Mussolini’s Italy or Hitler’s Germany.

The reader is wondering at this moment what I mean by these abstract and generalized phrases and horrific comparisons, and here I am trying to link them to developments in the Israeli political arena, which often does not lend itself easily to comprehensive analysis. What is the connection between the drumbeat of war on Iran, the rise in tomato prices in vegetable markets, the transfer of funds to the Palestinian Authority against the backdrop of demonstrations in West Bank cities, the dismissal of the civics education inspector in the Israeli Ministry of Education, the recommendation to close the political science department at Beersheba University, and the government recommendation to recognize Ariel College, located in the occupied Palestinian territories, as the seventh university in Israel?

At first glance, the connection seems to be a coincidence; the Iranian nuclear issue has been present on the political, security, and media scene for some time, the transfer of funds to the Authority is a requirement based on the Paris Agreement of 1995, the rise in the price of tomatoes is a seasonal issue, the dismissal of the civics inspector is a professional decision, as is the recommendation to close the political science department at Beersheba University, and the recommendation to recognize Ariel College as a university, which is the only one that can smell the scent of a political decision and which is difficult to wrap in a naivety.

However, these issues, especially the decisions related to the civil education or higher education sector, are not a coincidence. The Iranian bogeyman is the cover through which many other decisions are passed and portrayed as unrelated to each other, and the transfer of funds to the Authority is a purchase of security silence that enables the Israeli government to continue the process of building and expanding settlements without much challenge. The successive decisions on education and higher education also reflect the attempts of the nationalist capitalist right to dominate the Israeli political mindset and impose its will on the political agenda in Israel. The penetration of all public institutions, especially those that shape opinion and form historical and cultural awareness and have political consequences, is part of the same political system that seeks to ensure silence and compliance in order to pass long-term political plans. These successive decisions are in addition to the legalization processes that have been passed in the Knesset in the past three years, most notably the Nakba Law, the Boycott Law, and the Citizenship Law, as well as the judicial and administrative procedures that aimed to narrow the scope of freedom of expression and limit the possibilities of political movement that contradicts the intellectual system that seeks to dominate Israeli society. This plan, which takes many forms and directions, has been a “Herutian” obsession since the days of Jabotinsky and has become a “Likudist” one since the late 1970s. During that period, and we are talking about the years of Likud rule during the era of Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir, Likud was unable to dominate absolutely because it did not have control over the basic cultural, academic and media institutions in the country, as the social forces created by the “Labor” party were still exercising control over the centers of influence in the scientific, cultural and media institutions; and this sought to control these institutions in the last ten years, as the Likud governments of Sharon and then Netanyahu worked to penetrate these institutions and change them from within, and the political appointments of Tzachi Hanegbi and his ilk are nothing but an expression of the programmed transformation of the political and cultural orientations that express the Zionist-Israeli project, based on the “iron wall”. In the places where these attempts could not advance, they created alternatives or competitors with the “controversial” institutions.

Share the article:

Recent Posts

Test

Marzouq Halabi: The ethics of a tiring profession

The film insulting the Prophet and the West’s double standards regarding freedom of expression

Israeli elections between changing personalities and stable policies

Her Majesty’s Service

Land Day from the perspective of the Israeli media

Related Articles

Test

Hello

Marzouq Halabi: The ethics of a tiring profession

Professional ethics are the principles, “rules” and “systems” that have accumulated within the framework of a specific profession throughout its history and through the efforts of those in charge of it. Any discussion of ethics is ultimately a philosophical approach that goes back to the origin of the profession and those values ​​that exist at its foundation. In its beginning, they are those regulating rules that frame a specific human activity that later turned into a profession.

The film insulting the Prophet and the West’s double standards regarding freedom of expression

My evening was not ordinary, it was burdened with news from the Arab and Islamic world about protests against the production of a film insulting the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, called “Innocence of Muslims.” Part of those demonstrations were indeed in support of the noble Prophet, and another part seemed to me to be recording a political stance, nothing more. Regardless, I decided to escape from this huge amount of news to my imaginary world, where I practice my human nature and listen to songs that help me reconcile with myself and clear my mind to advance with the mentality of a warrior to the upcoming battles.

Israeli elections between changing personalities and stable policies

The results of the recent Israeli elections have sparked widespread controversy over several issues related to the relationship between expectations and the course of the elections on the one hand, and their political and partisan results and the structure of the government coalition on the other hand.