Land Day from the perspective of the Israeli media

2013-08-02

Nabih Bashir

It has become clear to all of us that the various media outlets are not a channel that transmits the public mood to the government and legislative apparatus and vice versa, i.e. transmits the decisions and the prevailing mood among politicians to the public, but rather a means of crystallizing and taming public opinion by providing certain indications, vocabulary and information and linking some of them to each other, thus drawing a “logical” picture that is difficult for the “idle” reader to penetrate and analyze; from this perspective, the media is considered an integral part of the apparatuses of the dominant state or nation, and results from the goals of those apparatuses and their interactions with each other. As part of the apparatuses of the state and the dominant elite in Israeli society, it is considered an exclusionary apparatus that reinforces the marginalization of the marginalized and feeds on the public consensus (exclusionary Zionist) sometimes, and produces it at other times.

For ideological, political and marketing reasons, the media often uses symbolic connotations and vocabulary to transform an event into a more tragic event than it actually is, leaving deep effects on the reader’s consciousness, such as raising mental associations and the specter of a personal threat, especially when talking about marginalized groups in society, such as national minorities and groups of political “deviant” (such as demonstrators), which subsequently leads to the depoliticization of the manifestations of protest and the demands of demonstrators. All of this is based on concepts and terms derived from the “social problem” school, such as chaos, violence, sabotage, anti-Semitism, and others. The research literature, in the period following the 1973 war, stopped at the sudden transformation in the role of the Israeli press represented by self-criticism regarding the marginalization of the role of the fourth estate (the various media) in monitoring the work and activities of the government apparatuses in Israel; This shift cannot be seen through the Israeli media’s coverage of Arab society, but rather this shift was limited to its coverage of Jewish society issues only. The Israeli media – in all its forms and channels – continued to adopt the position of the Israeli establishment, both political and security, and at best referred to the “opinions” of some Arab leaders and put them in quotation marks. If we rely on the reports of the newspaper “Haaretz” as a model of the Israeli media from the day the decision to strike was made on March 30, 1976 (a decision that was made in mid-February), it becomes clear that the newspaper had described the strike since March 3 as a serious threat to political and social stability in the country, and described the strike before it happened (from March 3 to 29) as a “day of unrest” and “brutal violence,” using terms drawn from the world of crime: “violence,” “incitement,” “chaos,” “unrest,” “barbarism,” “stones,” and others, and that it was actually a conflict between the Jewish and Arab communities in the country; The reasons for this decision were summarized as being due to the intensity of the “serious incitements” internally and externally, and the objection to the “Jewish presence in the Galilee”; and it went on to say that the state institutions must deal with the strike and its leaders based on the concept of shock and the reliance on repressive apparatuses such as the police, “security forces,” and violent tools; and it explained that after the day of the strike, a large number of deaths and serious physical injuries among the demonstrators were caused by the intensity of the “violence of the demonstrators.” Journalists obtained their information during this period exclusively from security sources and Jewish political officials, all of which was done in order to legitimize the use of military force and extreme police violence against the demonstrators, and to depoliticize the strike, in addition to using Hebrew expressions with special connotations such as the expression “מאורעות / Meorot” (events), which is often used in the Zionist lexicon to describe the killings and massacres that were inflicted on Jews in Europe from the Middle Ages to the modern era. The Israeli press reports covering the general strike on March 30, 1976, were characterized by their persistent efforts to empty the political content of all aspects of the Arab protests, demonstrations, speeches, and festivals that took place before and during Land Day, especially those civil contents, and replace them with connotations and content taken from the dictionaries of traditional criminology, anti-Semitism, absurd violence, and destructive anarchism that has no goal other than destruction, violence, and killing, and which are based on the idea that violence and destruction are the same goal and do not carry political connotations; in addition to that, of course, the implicit or explicit reliance on the idea of ​​eternal hostility to the Jews, which is nourished by the saying of the ancient Jewish jurists: “Esau hated [eternally] Jacob,” which summarizes the mentality that all people are hostile to the Jews, not because of their behavior or ideas, but simply because they are Jews. However, in some articles and few reports on this base, the statement appears that the goal of this “riot”, “violence” and “sabotage” is to “demand regional separation from the state” and to object to the Jewish presence in the Galilee, but all these demands and objections have a criminal and provocative character more than they carry political and civil goals. Also, one of the results of the research in the Israeli press reports is to portray the strike, and the mass activity surrounding it, as a threat to the political and social reality in the state, in addition to being a conflict and confrontation with the Jewish community as a whole, not with the arms of the state and its policies. Some researchers also revealed to us that the Israeli media used the language of “threat” in addressing the Arab population, their leaders and their masses, as if it were a military or police party to the conflict, and that it rejected all the reasons and justifications that prompted the Arab leaders to announce the strike, and completely identified with all the justifications of the police, the army, and the Israeli political and security leadership. The Israeli media paved the way for the strike many days before the strike to completely delegitimize it and conceal its civil and political implications and demands. It relied on many…

Share the article:

Recent Posts

Test

Marzouq Halabi: The ethics of a tiring profession

The film insulting the Prophet and the West’s double standards regarding freedom of expression

Amal Jamal: Chance and Politics

Israeli elections between changing personalities and stable policies

Her Majesty’s Service

Related Articles

Test

Hello

Marzouq Halabi: The ethics of a tiring profession

Professional ethics are the principles, “rules” and “systems” that have accumulated within the framework of a specific profession throughout its history and through the efforts of those in charge of it. Any discussion of ethics is ultimately a philosophical approach that goes back to the origin of the profession and those values ​​that exist at its foundation. In its beginning, they are those regulating rules that frame a specific human activity that later turned into a profession.

The film insulting the Prophet and the West’s double standards regarding freedom of expression

My evening was not ordinary, it was burdened with news from the Arab and Islamic world about protests against the production of a film insulting the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, called “Innocence of Muslims.” Part of those demonstrations were indeed in support of the noble Prophet, and another part seemed to me to be recording a political stance, nothing more. Regardless, I decided to escape from this huge amount of news to my imaginary world, where I practice my human nature and listen to songs that help me reconcile with myself and clear my mind to advance with the mentality of a warrior to the upcoming battles.

Amal Jamal: Chance and Politics

I would like to start by questioning whether politics and chance are companions; in politics there are no coincidences, and in coincidence there is no politics. This does not mean that certain political decisions cannot appear or be proposed as if they were the result of chance. Politics harnesses chance to remove the political character from politics and present it as a mere coincidence in order to limit objection to it or not alert those who object to it. And it, politics, sometimes means presenting certain matters as mere coincidence in order to erase their political character, despite prior planning and despite the clear calculations of profit and loss in the matter.