Article by: Zakaria Mohareb
The following article is not an analytical one regarding Israeli cinema; it is merely impressions that emerged after watching the Israeli film “Bethlehem,” which was co-written alongside the Israeli Yuval Adler, a director from Jaffa, Ali Waked. The viewing, which drew me to return to the cinema, hoping to find answers to many internal questions, the most important being: “Is this the Palestinian?!”
Many will claim that the film is propaganda and serves a Zionist agenda, with a prime example being the columns of criticism that labeled it as a public relations tool for the Israeli General Security Service (Shabak) (see Walla) and others who described it as skillfully promoting Israeli security agendas (see Haaretz, especially Gideon Levy’s article). So why bother at all?! But this will explain much of the Western world’s sympathy toward the Israeli narrative, where there is a clear and unified Palestinian strategy to expose it and reveal its falsehood. The absence of such a strategy, with precise Israeli planning and Palestinian-Arab indifference, has turned the perpetrator into a victim, which clarifies even more why the film’s protagonist was called “Smurf,” who betrayed “Sherbiel” (the Shabak officer in our case)!
It is important to begin by addressing the events of the film. “Bethlehem” provides a glimpse into the dark world of the Israeli Intelligence Service, the Shabak, where the most effective way to activate an agent is through those closest to them.
The film depicts the complex relationships between Razi (Tzachi Halevi), the Shabak officer in charge of Bethlehem, and Smurf (Shadi Mar’i), the younger brother of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigade leader in the city, Ibrahim. Razi recruits Smurf as an agent when he is 15, and invests a long time in building their relationship. Smurf, who grew up under the care of his older brother, sees Razi as both a friend and a father figure, someone who believes in him and relies on him.
Now, at 17, Smurf tries to maneuver between Razi’s demands and his loyalty to his brother, finding himself leading a double life and forced to lie to both sides. When the Shabak discovers Smurf’s involvement in his brother’s operations, Razi and Smurf find themselves in a difficult position.
Later, Smurf’s brother, Ibrahim, is assassinated after Razi sends Smurf away from Bethlehem to protect him. After the assassination, Smurf grows closer to the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades and reveals his identity. The Brigades offer him two choices: either be executed or carry out a revenge operation—killing his friend Razi.
Smurf meets Razi and initially tries to convince him to take him to Tel Aviv. After Razi refuses, Smurf brutally kills him.
What I mentioned is just a general summary of the film’s events, but the film includes many statements that significantly contributed to reinforcing preconceived negative ideas about Arabs, the most prominent being lying, betrayal, and treason.
The film begins with a phone call between Shabak officer Razi and an agent named Abu Yunis, where Razi provocatively asks, “Abu Yunis, why did humans invent language?” To which Abu Yunis responds, “So they can lie.” And that is what we see throughout the film: Arabs always lie, they only tell the truth when manipulated, insulted, or threatened. Smurf lies to Razi, the leader of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Ibrahim, lies to his resistance comrades, and the representative of the Palestinian Liberation Organization lies to the Palestinian families, and so on!
The film also depicts the Shabak as the largest operator of Palestinian youth in the West Bank. The information gathered did not come from Smurf alone but from numerous informants. Moreover, the assassination of Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades leader, Ibrahim, was based on intelligence gathered and monitored by many informants!
Additionally, the film portrays the Palestinian Brigades as only working for money. Greed is their primary motivator, not resistance or fighting the occupation. The film shows that Ibrahim, the leader of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, betrayed his friends and received money from Hamas in exchange for carrying out suicide operations inside Israel! Furthermore, Ibrahim never informed his friends; he sent his younger brother to collect the money, risking his life. This shows the greed for money and nothing but money. Even when Ibrahim went to collect the money from a shopkeeper, who entrusted him with the payment and offered him coffee, Ibrahim reminded him that his brother owed him money. He spoke to him in a “thug-like” manner, threatening him, “Tell your brother to bring the money… I haven’t forgotten.”
Another scene in the film shows a large group of Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades waiting for a Palestinian official at his doorstep for hours in exchange for money. Another scene shows the Brigades blocking a minister’s car and firing in the air, causing him to flee, then later attacking an official’s office and threatening him with weapons to pay them.
The film also emphasizes the idea that “there is no safety for Arabs.” The humane treatment by Razi toward Smurf was met with brutality from Smurf. The term “habibi,” which Razi used to address Smurf, cost him his life. Smurf not only shoots Razi but crushes his skull with a large stone until he dies! The “breaking bones” policy is recalled in two cases: first, from the 1984 Bus 300 incident, where the army killed four Palestinian militants (Jamal Mahmoud Isa Abu Jami’ah, Majdi Ahmad Abu Jami’ah, Subhi Shihada Abu Jami’ah, and Muhammad Subhi Barakah) who tried to hijack a bus to negotiate the release of prisoners. In an interview with Yedioth Ahronoth in 1996, one of the soldiers, Ehud Yatom, stated, “I smashed their skulls on orders from President Avraham Shalom, and I’m proud of everything I did.” The second case is from the first intifada in 1987, when the “man of peace,” Yitzhak Rabin, tried to suppress the uprising through violence but failed, prompting international condemnation of the brutal Israeli tactics. Rabin, based on American advice, ordered a different approach: breaking bones, stating that it was more effective than using live ammunition, as breaking bones, especially the hands, would prevent young people from participating in protests or throwing stones again! These two cases confirm that the tactic of smashing bones is not a Palestinian invention; it is uniquely Israeli, and it seems that the film’s producers are attempting to change the mental image in the viewer’s mind, who, even before watching the film, knew who was the architect of the “breaking bones” policy.
After discussing what the film presented, it is also worth addressing what the film did not present. “Bethlehem” begins when Razi has already recruited Smurf, but the viewer is never shown how Smurf, a minor, was recruited. What pressures were exerted on him to work with the Shabak? How was his vulnerability exploited for purely Israeli security purposes? The absence of this scene is not accidental; it further reinforces the film’s propaganda and its desperate attempt to polish the image of the Shabak and the occupation in general, leaving no room for sympathy toward Smurf.
Regarding intentions, the film talks about “Bethlehem,” which is, by nature, a Christian town, but all the characters in the film, except for one (the leader of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Ibrahim, who hid before his assassination), are Muslims! It seems that the film attempts to narrow and reduce the conflict to a religious one between Jews and Muslims, as if the conflict is religious and not political over land and place. This also explains the Israeli hatred for Muslims, even though the Christian brothers are fully partners in the Palestinian struggle and resistance, exemplified by figures like George Habash.
Clearly, the film, which claims to be based on documented Israeli facts and archives, appears to combine the story of the martyr Hassan Abu Shaera and parts of the story of the martyr Hamza Abu Sarour, both of whom taught the Shabak unforgettable lessons. This will be Israel’s global face, especially since it includes Arab actors and a co-writer as well! It is truly unfortunate that some of our best artists and creators participate in such works. If the excuse is the artistic blockade and the necessity of work, then it would be better for them to turn to other fields, such as teaching.