The Western Media and Its Role in Promoting Israeli Propaganda
Aatif Al-Sha’er
There is a clear difference between the American and European branches of Western media, even though both belong to capitalist worlds that share similarities and differences at the same time. The American Western media often seems more aggressive and foolish, particularly when it comes to Israel.
What the American media says on channels like “Fox News” and others affiliated with right-wing parties is sometimes worse than what the Israeli media itself says about Israel and its racist policies towards Arabs and Palestinians.
Undoubtedly, Israel is a product of the West. Since its inception by the Zionist movement, its leaders understood that major Western powers like Britain, France, and later the United States, were essential for its creation and continuity. Over the years, Israel has established organizations and associations to help market its policies and support its occupation and settlement activities, even its racist actions in Palestine. Initially, Israel succeeded in this to a large extent, as major countries recognized and praised its establishment, supporting it strongly at the expense of Palestinian Arab political and human rights. The Western support for Israel was also fueled by Israel’s ability to highlight the suffering of Jews in Europe, the existential and psychological devastation caused by Nazism and anti-Semitism. This garnered sympathy from many Westerners who felt guilty about what happened to the Jews in Europe, particularly when portrayed through the negative stereotypes of Arabs in the West, who were seen as having neither a rich culture nor a history, and whose land, Palestine, was falsely depicted as empty or belonging to a people unworthy of it.
Despite all this, the persistence of the Palestinian national movement and its activities throughout the 20th century changed the Western perception of Palestine and Palestinians significantly. Over time, Palestine has become a symbol of struggle for freedom and justice, gaining a place in global discourse on colonization and occupation. Palestinians now have a voice, albeit a faint one at times, in Western media. Though it is not as powerful or effective as needed, it is still noticeable.
American Media’s Blind Support for Israel
However, when discussing Western media and the influence of Israeli propaganda on it, we are talking about a complex and multi-faceted issue. There is no unified Western media, as there are many different outlets, and it is difficult to make sweeping generalizations with absolute certainty. Nevertheless, we can draw a few conclusions when reflecting on this subject.
One clear distinction is between American and European Western media. While both share a capitalist foundation, they differ in their approaches. American media, especially, is often more aggressive and foolish in its support for Israel. There is an ideological, blind, and deep allegiance to Israel, even towards its most aggressive actions. Sometimes, what is said on American channels like “Fox News” is worse than what the Israeli media itself says about Israel’s racist policies towards Arabs and Palestinians, whether in Gaza, the West Bank, or inside Israel, or even in the diaspora. Such media often portrays Palestinians as terrorists or a “surplus population,” confidently defending Israel’s policies, its democracy, and its proximity to Western values. As a result, Israeli propaganda about Palestinians and their rights finds many supporters in the United States, especially in mainstream media, both written and televised. Whenever any American president speaks about any Arab country, Israel and its security are always at the core of the conversation, revealing the deep penetration of Israeli propaganda in the American psyche, both consciously and unconsciously. The Israeli narrative of continuous existential threats is part of the American ideological discourse on the region, and anyone criticizing Israel is often labeled as anti-Semitic or as a Jew-hater, along with other false and inhumane accusations. However, some voices in the U.S. have emerged that offer significant space to the Palestinian narrative, such as “Democracy Now” and “The National” newspaper, which have hosted writings by the distinguished Palestinian intellectual, Professor Edward Said. These voices are often faint compared to the dominating ones, which are backed by powerful lobby groups such as AIPAC, but they are important, and there must be an active role from Arabs, both officially and unofficially, to support and strengthen them.
European Media, Except Germany, Shows Some Sympathy for Palestine
In Europe, the situation is different. There is generally more empathy and understanding for the Palestinian cause these days, although not to the extent needed. The situation varies from country to country. Germany, for example, continues to view Zionism positively and does not dare criticize Israel in any significant or sensitive way. The media there follows this approach, promoting Israeli policies. This is largely due to the deep-seated connection in many Germans’ minds between Israel’s creation and the crimes of Nazi Germany against Jews in the 1940s. Thus, the issue of guilt regarding the atrocities committed during the Nazi era plays a central role in the German culture and education system. However, this is not the case in Britain, where there is broader opposition to Israeli actions and a deeper, more objective analysis. The situation is similar in France, although certain Jewish communities in Europe exert influence and have media sway in these countries and their policies. In these countries, there are many programs that allow Arab intellectuals to speak about the Middle East and Israel’s policies. These programs also challenge Israeli spokespersons who have regularly promoted Israeli propaganda without opposition, especially on American channels. This openness extends to written media as well, with European authors writing honestly and humanely about Palestinians, disregarding Israeli propaganda and emphasizing Palestinian rights and their legitimacy.
Therefore, we can say with some confidence that Europe is generally more open to the Palestinian narrative and national rights. There is significant criticism of Israel on various channels, such as Britain’s “Channel 4” and liberal newspapers like “The Guardian” and “The Independent.” However, it is important to note that this does not mean the situation is uniformly supportive. Some European governments still align with Israel due to internal political and social pressures.
Israeli Propaganda in Western Media
Israeli propaganda is still very much alive in Western media, but it is no longer as dominant as it once was. In the past, it controlled almost every aspect of the media, and the Arab narrative had little chance of being understood by the Western audience. The shift in European media has been concerning for Israel, especially during periods of large-scale aggression, such as in its wars on Gaza in 2009 and 2012, where Israel revealed its colonial and aggressive nature. Israel has used intense propaganda campaigns through its embassies and lobbying groups to promote its narrative of being the only democracy in the Middle East and its close ties to the West, framing itself as a partner in the global war on terrorism. Yet, this narrative has failed to convince many Europeans, and European media in general, due to Israel’s violent and colonial mindset, which makes peace and coexistence with it difficult. Israel’s racist policies, such as the separation wall, are often depicted in European reports as symbols of colonial aggression, evoking comparisons to the Berlin Wall and other walls that divided people based on racial and national grounds.
European Windows of Opportunity
Based on the above, Palestinians and Arabs must continue to knock on the “doors and windows” of European media to spread their historical and political narrative, showing that they are an oppressed people living under an illegal and aggressive occupation that violates international law. To do this more effectively, Palestinians and Arabs need a skilled cadre that understands European languages and cultures, who knows how to engage with and converse with these cultures logically, rationally, and above all, humanely. The Palestinian cause, in its historical dimensions, is a human issue and requires someone who understands its deep human aspects and can convey it to others in a meaningful way. Ultimately, the truth will be heard, and justice will prevail.
*Professor at the University of London, of Palestinian origin, specializing in Arab studies, particularly in its literary and cultural aspects and their intersection with politics.