2013-10-11
By: Journalist Hamid Agbaria, Editor of “Sawt al-Haq wa al-Hurriya” Newspaper
When talking about the reality of economic media and journalism in Palestinian society inside Israel, it is impossible to separate it from the economic reality of our society. Just as our economic situation is deplorable, being a dependent, consumer-oriented, and non-productive economy with no collective economic aspirations, and content with crumbs, meaning that its main concern is, for the most part, daily survival and the costs of living at the individual and family level, and the continuity of life at the communal level, so is the situation of economic media in the interior. In truth, we cannot say we have economic media or economic journalism because economics is at the bottom of the priorities of local media. So, when you want to search for an economic piece of information, you will make a significant effort to find economic news here and there in this newspaper or that website, which are mostly news and information taken from Hebrew media, concerning individual issues more than communal ones, unless occasionally. These are pieces of news about taxes, the prices of basic goods, fuel prices, or currencies, and similar matters.
It can be said that there are two main reasons for this situation; the first concerns the priorities and interests of media outlets. Most media outlets (rarely excluded) focus on light entertainment topics that attract the audience, and perhaps occasionally address political and social issues (as a formal obligation!!), but even these are presented crudely and with negative consequences, which is not the subject of further detail here. The second reason is the lack of specialization in economic journalism. The majority of journalists working in local media lack the fundamental elements of journalistic work, and most are not specialized in media, let alone in any specific field such as economics or political science. Hence, media owners, who primarily care about financial profits, do not prioritize specialization. You find the journalist tackling all kinds of issues (only to discover that they master none of them), and consequently, media outlets do not dedicate economic sections that present ideas, solutions, and suggestions to address our community’s economic issues and living concerns. It is rare to find a media outlet (written or electronic) focusing on the economic file of Palestinian society inside Israel.
A third reason can be added to the above two, which is the economic consumerism of our society linked to the Israeli productive economy and its inability to escape the vicious circle. Undoubtedly, the economic file is closely related to the political (and intellectual and social) situation of our community. Since our community does not yet form a cohesive political, intellectual, and social unit, this situation is naturally reflected in the economic file, leaving us on the periphery of the Israeli economy. (When we talk about political, intellectual, and social coherence, we mean the prevailing nature of our community, which requires political leadership to guide it, and this leadership does not practically exist.)
In order to elevate economic media, there must be a motivation for this progress. The motivation, which I see, even if theoretically at this stage, is the transformation of our community inside Israel from mere consumers to active economic participants, on the path to becoming producers. This is only possible through a unified political-social-intellectual system that adopts the idea of a self-made community, building itself without waiting for the official institution to grant it crumbs. These crumbs should contribute to strengthening the community’s self-reliance, but they should not be the foundation or the only support (as is the case now) for our economic file.
With this understanding, and from this standpoint, we can start having effective economic media that is engaged with economic issues. I am not talking about the stock market or banks or heavy industries; I am talking about establishing the foundation for a form of economic independence (with a realistic understanding of our dependence on the Israeli economy…). Let me give an example: imagine 200 businessmen from inside Israel each contributing $100,000 to build a local economic project (let’s say a dairy products factory, just as an example). You would have $20 million, or about 80 million shekels. This is a large amount by our local standards and could lay the groundwork for other projects, contribute to solving part of the unemployment problem, and contribute to a productive local market rather than just a consumer one.
Additionally, I can add that serious local media, which genuinely cares about the concerns of our Palestinian community inside, could take the initiative to highlight successful examples of local economic initiatives and present them as models that prove we can build a local economy. This way, the media can help encourage new initiatives. But… in reality, we need a revolutionary or intellectual upheaval in how we deal with our economic situation, and this requires courage (not recklessness or suicide as some may perceive it) and a belief in our ability to change the economic situation from dependence to a form of independence or self-sufficiency, even if only in some branches of the economy that have a consumer-oriented nature.