2016-07-18
Amal Jamal
General Manager of Media Center – Nazareth
There are those who call for separating national political work from civil work, claiming that parliamentary work should prioritize civil issues, leaving national work to other contexts. Others protest the style of some Arab lawmakers, without disagreeing with the content of what they say. These critics argue that the approach of some lawmakers is provocative and thus limited in its ability to convey their legitimate demands to the Jewish community and the government in an appropriate manner.
I must admit that I am among those who argue that there are different levels of political work, and we should plan for them, separating objectives according to our interests. However, some have taken this separation to unintended levels, which fail to realize the full potential of political work. Demanding that Arab lawmakers focus solely on civil demands reduces our political legitimacy as members of a people that the ruling establishment seeks to erase from reality, limiting us to a civil identity defined by them. Furthermore, focusing solely on the style of these lawmakers obscures the Israeli oppressive reality and the efforts to delegitimize Arab leadership.
The separation between national and civil political work is fundamentally an analytical cognitive distinction that cannot be fully realized in reality. The national cause frames civil political work, giving it its unique character, while civil work allows national political activity to express itself in its true form, as it sees fit. We claim that this is unjust. This injustice is civil, but it is based on our national identity. Therefore, we demand civil rights based on our Palestinian Arab identity, which has been denied, marginalized, and violated on this basis. On the other hand, we demand equal civil rights despite our identity and to preserve it – legitimizing it as an inseparable part of our civil identity that the state attempts to truncate and subject to the Jewish majority’s identity in the country, which denies our rights to the land and the time we live in.
It is true that Palestine cannot be liberated from the Knesset podium, nor can internal issues related to the Arab community be resolved from the parliament that enacts discriminatory laws against this community. However, it must be emphasized that these discriminatory laws are enacted not because we are ordinary citizens, but because we are Arabs, Palestinians, and part of a people that the Israeli government does not want to exist or be liberated. Therefore, this issue cannot and should not be separated from our civil identity. It should be emphasized that it has a special character, without falling into the trap of isolation and closure. Instead, we must call for changes in Israeli civil life to align with our identity, not the other way around.
The rights system is not a given or found in ready-made legal texts. It is an ongoing process of formulation that reflects the dynamics of society. The system of rights is a reflection of what has been formulated based on the power relationships in a specific historical context, and it is difficult to change it without altering the power dynamics that created it. Therefore, Israeli law and its definition of rights have structurally favored the rights of the Jewish majority, and the interpretations of Israeli courts only confirm, deepen, and entrench the legitimacy of the Jewish majority in the country over time, space, and resources. The mental and cognitive structure embedded in Israeli law assumes the existence of the Jewish community and history before the Israeli citizenship system, as reflected in the Israeli Law of Return. Therefore, any interpretation of the law reaffirms the secondary status of Arabs and their subordination to a state that aligns with the vision of Jews for themselves and the country.
This is the core of the conflict that must be managed, which boils down to the collision between prioritizing Jewish identity in law and the true concept of citizenship, which should have no exclusionary identity. Citizenship cannot be limited to one segment of the population while excluding others, if it is to be genuine. Citizens are those who have the right to have rights, and these rights can only be equal if we are to talk about the essential meaning of citizenship. This is the goal of exercising civil life: achieving rights based on the right of citizens to have rights and sovereignty over the state. This means that civil political work aims to remove the factors that obscure the rights of those who have the right to them and who are wronged in their rights. This work can be managed through dialogue within the rights system, even if it does not meet basic conditions due to its bias toward a certain group of citizens.
It is correct to say that there is no non-national civil discourse in Israel because the Israeli “civil” discourse is of a Jewish character, and as such, it is unjust to anyone who is not Jewish, especially if they are Palestinian. On the other hand, the claim of democracy in Israel is the platform from which the contradiction between democratic civil discourse and Israeli “civil” discourse can be clarified. This makes the Israeli parliament and the public sphere spaces through which we must work to clarify the contradictory nature of the Israeli political and legal discourse. Some claim that clarifying this contradiction is a foregone conclusion, and that Israeli society is inherently racist and cannot change its positions. Others claim that the entrenched master mentality in the Jewish Israeli consciousness cannot give up its privileges voluntarily. Even if these claims are correct, those who do not believe in the possibility of influencing through the parliament and use the platform merely to convey political messages that do not intend to affect may not know how effective their parliamentary work is, unless they aim to exacerbate the already exacerbated situation. Therefore, we cannot give up the opportunity to address the public conscience in Israel and the world about the racism inherent in the Israeli political and legal system and expose its flaws through mechanisms imposed by our civil status. Those most capable of doing this are those with direct experience, who are familiar with political language and understand the peculiarities of the Israeli mentality.
Thus, addressing the other becomes an important goal in itself, as communication is both a civil and national duty. Giving up the possibility of change, even as a latent force in reality, can be considered a violation of the interests that political representation originally seeks to fulfill. This means that the methods of discourse must be diverse and subject to foundational considerations: changing reality by altering the dominant mentality through will and persuasion, in order to ensure the morality of the struggle and its intellectual and practical consistency.
Inviting the addressee and simulating their conscience and logic according to circumstances is a political engineering process that cannot be underestimated. It is correct to say that no right is lost if there is someone to claim it. However, the form of the claim becomes an important factor in legitimizing or delegitimizing the demand, because style can become an independent factor that provides clear indications of the content of the demand, its truth, and its credibility. The content of discourse derives part of its meaning through its style, and separating the two is merely a justifying trick. All the philosophers of rhetoric have claimed that the alignment between content and style strengthens discourse and supports it cognitively, ethically, and mentally.
One of the important aspects of parliamentary work is challenging the dominant political and legal discourse, exposing its flaws, and unveiling the implicit value and moral hierarchy in it. This view of parliamentary work takes into account that this work does not merely define policies and allocate resources for implementing projects, as Arab lawmakers are not part of the decision-making body in the government coalition. The government is called upon to ensure fairness and equality in resource distribution. The function of parliamentary work for the opposition is to deconstruct the discourse and principles of resource distribution policy, exposing the prioritization of policies not to record a political stance but to hold a mirror up to the parliamentary majority, exposing its moral inconsistency and demonstrating the contradiction between its claim to democracy and the blatant discrimination it practices.
This rhetorical work comes with the hope of persuading decision-makers to reconsider their intentions and adhere to the moral and humanitarian principles that should guide the decision-making process. Persuasion and influence are essential; otherwise, there is no logic to parliamentary work. To persuade, we must develop rhetorical mechanisms capable of overcoming the repressed psychological state that explodes every time it tries to deliver its message and is obstructed. We must use not only language capable of penetrating the dominant discourse but also language capable of presenting better ethical and cognitive alternatives. We are not talking about a magical one-sided equation but about an approach that was once prevalent in Arab political discourse and is still adopted by some who, although they occasionally aimed for provocation to achieve a television image, worked to present an alternative vision to that of the authority through wise and persuasive discourse, taking into account the unwillingness of the dominant Israeli leadership to listen to them. The principled language—whether theoretical or historical—that can rise above the actual and specific reality to pose ethical, mental, and cognitive challenges and convey important messages, relying on the intelligence of the listeners to apply the principle spoken about to the intended situation, is the best language for struggles. The sharp historical examples, such as Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela, and Mahatma Gandhi, are a prime example of this. These figures were well aware of and personally felt the brutality of the political system they spoke to, and they knew that the moral conscience was absent among the majority of those who supported that system. Nevertheless, they maintained a rational and ethical discourse. We can only refer to these figures as historical examples of successful political change despite harsh conditions and their severity. We are in need and capable of mastering the language of King, Mandela, and Gandhi without falling into the traps of theatrics that undermine the seriousness of our humanitarian struggle for our rights, or in provocations that are unnecessary. Delivering the message in a way that breaks through the barriers of hearing within the ruling institution, the Jewish majority, and, equally importantly, international institutions, is at the heart of national political work through civil mechanisms that we urgently need today.