The incitement against Palestinians in Israeli media has become an unquestionable norm that doesn’t disturb any of us, nor does it prompt us to devise a clear strategy to confront and counter this rhetoric. It has become an integral part of our reality. Some Israeli politicians and journalists use media platforms, both traditional and social media, to advance their right-wing and racist agendas toward Palestinians, shaping public opinion according to this rejected and despised discourse.
A quantitative report prepared by “I’lam” – the Arab Center for Media Freedom, Development, and Research – reveals the extent of the spread of incitement and racist discourse in Israeli media. It provides an analysis of the level of incitement in various media outlets, the Palestinian groups most targeted, and the types of incitement used. The report covers the period from January to June of the current year, during which 452 cases of incitement and racism against Palestinians in the interior, the West Bank, and Gaza Strip were documented.
The findings show that the most inciting platform against Palestinians is the social media network “Facebook” at 31%, due to its accessibility and lack of content moderation, followed by the newspaper “Israel Hayom” with 13%, the newspaper “Maariv” with 8%, and both “Yedioth Ahronoth” and “Twitter” at 7%. As for the Palestinian segments most targeted, it is clear that the Palestinian society as a whole is the most targeted with incitement, at 25% of the cases, followed by the Palestinian Authority at 22%, the political leadership in the interior at 16%, and Palestinians in the West Bank at 12%.
The report also addresses the types of inciting discourse used against the Palestinian community. It appears that the most commonly used type of incitement is delegitimizing the Palestinian community, at 74%, especially regarding its legitimacy to exist on the land of Palestine and its right to self-determination, followed by racist discourse based on religious or cultural grounds at 64%. Demonization and generalization were used at 55%, racial superiority at 43%, and the legitimization of collective punishment and the use of force at 14%. Additionally, many Israeli journalists tend to depict the occupation and Israeli society as victims in the conflict, and this rhetoric was used in 28% of the cases. It is worth noting that the majority of articles contain more than one type of incitement within the same article.
These results do not change based on security developments or political updates, but rather represent a systematic and targeted policy against Palestinian society wherever it may be, in every circumstance, although the intensity may vary. The results of a more comprehensive and in-depth monitoring period (from July 2017 to July 2019) show that social media networks are indeed the most dangerous platform for Palestinians, with incitement on “Facebook” at 26%, followed by “Twitter” at a significant 10%. As for newspapers and news channels, “Yedioth Ahronoth” and “Maariv” topped the list with 9% incitement, followed by “Israel Hayom” and Channel 20 (right-wing) at 8%, and “Yated Ne’eman” and “Hamodia” (religious) at 7% and 5%, respectively. As for the targeted Palestinian groups, it appears that the Palestinian Authority and Palestinian society as a whole are the most targeted, at 20% and 19%, respectively, followed by the Palestinian president at 15%, and the political leadership in the interior of Palestine at 14%. Palestinians within Israel were targeted in 10% of the cases.
We all know that the dominant Israeli discourse is full of incitement and racism in various arenas such as the parliament, the media, and other forms of communication. This discourse has become more aggressive over time compared to previous periods, such as the 1990s, for example. It is the result of political exploitation by right-wing parties to shape the public sentiment and determine what type of public discourse is acceptable. Israel’s selective, discriminatory, and repressive policies have been known since its establishment. However, what distinguishes recent years from previous ones is the legal codification of these policies and their open imposition on the ground, making them a taboo that cannot be touched. Evidence of this is the “Nation-State Law,” which has long recognized that Palestinian citizens are second-class citizens, but this law codified this selective policy and incorporated it into the state’s basic laws. Other examples include the dominance of extremist right-wing discourse in the political arena, such as the annexation of the West Bank and the imposition of Israeli sovereignty over it. This discourse has an overtly racial superiority character, as exemplified in a tweet by right-wing Transportation Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who claimed: “An iron fist for anyone who attacks our soldiers and police officers. But yes, I care if the attacker is Arab or Jewish. There is no comparison between a brother and an enemy. If they are Jews, it hurts me more. On the other hand, I deal with my brothers differently, even if they are criminals.”
It is time for us to awaken from this slumber, to internalize knowledge, and translate it into action on the ground, whether on international or local platforms. It is time for all political factions, despite their differences, to unite and craft a single political discourse that attracts all the latent energies within us, which have been fragmented and wasted due to the loss of our national compass. It is time to set a clear strategy for action and struggle aimed at changing the reality. Change is not the result of a moment, but rather the fruit of long-term struggle, with a well-planned strategy and proper utilization of existing energies.